Mind the Gap! Understanding current practice of front line health care workers as information providers to patients:
implications for service direction Michelle Helliwell, MLIS, BA, Library and Knowledge Management Services
Shared Services (Dalhousie School of Nursing - Yarmouth Site, Annapolis Valley Health, South Shore Health, South West Health)
Eastern Kings Memorial Community Health Centre
Question: The primary goal of this study was to assess the current practice of health care providers in their role as
information providers to patients. Results would assist in service planning for the information management of patient
education materials.
Design: This was a descriptive statistical study. A survey of 20 multiple choice and free text questions were delivered in
both paper and electronic survey format.
Setting: The survey took place across three District Health Authorities (DHAs) in western Nova Scotia.
Participants: 114 Front line HCPs across multiple disciplines and practice environments (nursing floors, community
health centres) were the target of this survey.
Results: 71% of HCPs lacked the time to find and assemble patient education materials, and that 1/3 of nurses reported spending at least 25% of their time looking for, collecting, and providing material to patients. Patient-orientated books are available to 62% of HCPs, but only 5% preferred them. Information types HCPs wanted and could not find included information about local services, self-directed care information and wellness information. 84% of HCPs reported seldom or never using Library Services' search services for patient education information requests.
Conclusion: The results of this study were instrumental in highlighting services gaps for Library Services in the realm of
patient education materials provision, and in the development of best practice standards for the information management of
patient education materials in the DHAs. These standards range from the selection and/or creation of material, usage,
availability, access and education for health care workers.
A Comparative Analysis of Librarians and Health Professionals as "Health Info(r)mediators" Nadine Wathen, PhD, Faculty of Information & Media Studies, The University of Western Ontario, London, On and
Leslie Bella, PhD, Research Professor, School of Social Work, Memorial University of Newfoundland and
Sally Wyatt, PhD, Virtual Knowledge Studio for the Humanities and Social Sciences, Royal Netherlands Academy of
Arts & Sciences, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Objectives: The public is being bombarded with health information from sources with different and sometimes conflicting
interests. The new concept of 'health info(r)mediation' denotes the processes through which health information is
provided to users. This paper explains how librarians and information specialists are central to the effectiveness of
the info(r)mediation work of health professionals.
Methods: A comparative analysis of the codes of practice and
training materials of librarianship, medicine, social work, nursing, dietetics and nutrition, and pharmacy, focusing on
involvement in patient / client education.
Results: These health professions are all involved in health info(r)mediation,
with some more concerned about patient compliance and others about patient self determination. Their info(r)mediation
practices are affected by the emergence of internet-based health information. Librarians are central to the production
and management of health information systems, building collections, writing finding aids and helping people who approach
the reference desk. Health librarians also construct systems used by health professionals to access current information
about illness and treatment. Ultimately, the future effectiveness of the info(r)mediation work of these five health
professions will depend on foundations built by librarians and information technology specialists who produce and
manage health information systems and help others to use them.
Discussion: Our findings about health info(r)mediation
will be discussed in the broader context of emerging socio-technical configurations in the production, consumption, and
regulation of health information.
Bridging the Divide Between Consumer Health and Evidence-Based Information Lori Giles-Smith, Neil John Maclean Health Sciences Library, University of Manitoba Health Sciences Libraries, Winnipeg and Christine Shaw-Daigle, University of Manitoba Hospital Librarian, Victoria General Hospital
Objective
To develop a value-added resource that combines consumer health media reports with evidence-based medical information
for physicians.
Setting
Through a number of media sources, today's consumers have unprecedented access to health information of varying
reliability and authority. Empowered by this information, patients are becoming more involved in their health decisions,
and are more willing to question the advice received from physicians. This is challenging for physicians, who must now
find time to read mass media health reports in addition to medical research. In order to help physicians with this task,
the University of Manitoba Health Sciences Libraries created What Your Patient Reads.
Audience
Physicians and medical residents working in Winnipeg's hospitals.
Program
The What Your Patient Reads service involves scanning local and national print and electronic media sources, and creating
a briefing connecting the reports with medical evidence. Each one-page synopsis contains a summary of the news report,
reference to the cited research, key points from both the news report and cited research, and related medical evidence.
These reports will prepare physicians for questions from their patients by making them aware of the media reports and
pointing them to literature that can either support or refute the claims.
Conclusion
The Health Sciences Libraries has identified a shift in consumer health literacy habits, and in response has developed
a value-added project to help physicians become aware of health reports in the media. This will allow them to anticipate
and answer patient questions with authority and confidence.
Collaborating with the Teaching Doctor: An Evolving Informatics Approach Sarah Wickett, Health Informatics Librarian, Bracken Health Sciences Library, Queen's University
Program objective: The position of Health Informatics Librarian was created to help professors in the Faculty of
Health Sciences use innovative information resources to improve teaching. By providing access to electronic
multimedia resources the library contributes to an increase in the relevance, integration, and interactivity
within the health sciences curricula, resulting in a reduction in the amount of didactic teaching.
Setting: Bracken Health Sciences Library at Queen's University in Kingston.
Participants: The library serves users in the schools of Medicine, Nursing, and Rehabilitation Therapy as well as
Life Sciences and Biochemistry programs. In total, the library supports over 700 faculty members.
Program: By providing a range of informatics services and resources, Bracken Health Sciences Library and the Health
Informatics Librarian play a central role in helping faculty improve their teaching. For example, a new partnership
between the library, Office of Health Sciences Education, and Medical Education Technology Unit provides faculty with
a single source for requesting and receiving help with any teaching question be it resource-based, technological, or
pedagogical. Also, by identifying and/or purchasing resources such as image collections, 3D anatomical models, and videos,
the library provides access to many valuable teaching tools and helps faculty move beyond books and journals as sources of
information. In focusing on collaboration with faculty, the Health Informatics Librarian is able to provide timely,
responsive and innovative solutions to common teaching concerns.
Results: After two years in the position of Health Informatics Librarian the author has seen a marked increase
in the numbers of requests and collaborations around technological resources for teaching.
Conclusion: Librarians who support faculty in any teaching setting (classroom, clinic, bedside) will learn useful tips
for creating a health informatics strategy at their institutions.
Health sciences librarians in Europe Iona Robu, Director of the library at the Université de Médecine et de Pharmacie in Cluj-Napoca, Romania
The aim of this presentation is to provide an overview of EAHIL (European Association for Health Information and Libraries), including the mission and objectives of the association, its organization, its members, as well as the main projects under way. The most recent evolution after the integration of former communist countries in the European Union will be also briefly described, with a focus on health sciences librarianship in Romania and the projects being developed in this country.
Objective: To assess the relative size and coverage of consumer health collections in public libraries in different countries.
Citizens are expected to take increasing responsibility for their own health. An important aspect of this responsibility
involves staying informed about health-related matters, especially 'healthy living', and being able to participate
in an informed manner in decision-making related to medical treatment. Although the internet plays a significant role
in the health information seeking practices of many lay citizens, in some countries the public library is an important
site of health information resources. A recent study in the U.K. revealed, for instance, that library patrons rated public
libraries among their most trusted sources of health information, second only to doctors. In this presentation,
we explore how support for users' consumer health information needs is expressed in the collections available to
patrons of public libraries in six countries.
Methods: The holdings within several Dewey classifications that reflect mainstream and alternative health resources
were tabulated for public library systems drawn from a random sample of mid-sized cities in six countries:
the United Kingdom, Italy, Austria, Australia, Canada and the United States.
Results: We will present findings comparing the relative size of collections and the emphases on different types of health
information material (reflected in the distribution of items across Dewey classification numbers) available in public
library collections in several countries.
Discussion: We will discuss our results in terms of the roles played by public libraries in different countries in support of consumer health information.
Repository Redux: UPEI virtual research environment Mark Leggott, University Librarian, University of Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown, PE
Objective: The Robertson Library at the University of Prince Edward Island embarked on the development of a comprehensive program for the stewardship of information resources in the three primary academic "landscapes": administration, learning and research. The VRE or Virtual Research Environment is a collaborative research environment supporting all stages of the research life cycle.
Methods: The VRE is being developed using the open source Drupal and Fedora systems as the two primary components and is compared with more traditional models for institutional repositories, which have not always met with the anticipated success. The session will also touch on aspects of capacity building and staff development at a small academic institution which are enabled by the use of open source applications.
Results: There are a number of VREs currently in production at UPEI, with a particular focus on the biosciences including generic collaborative tools as well as vertical applications that provide repository functions of interest to specific research areas. This session will present some of the elements of the VRE that would be of particular interest to health-related research.
Discussion: Issues and challenges encountered in developing the VRE model will be discussed, including the how the VRE project was used to build capacity in a young team and issues when an academic library engages the research community in new ways.
New roles for health sciences librarians in disaster response Robin Featherstone, National Library of Medicine Associate
Qualitative Study
Question: What are the roles for medical librarians in disaster planning, response and recovery? Setting:
National Library of Medicine in Bethesda, Maryland. Participants: Librarians from across North America who responded
to a wide range of disaster situations, such as hurricanes, epidemic outbreaks, and terrorist attacks.
Methods: Interviews were conducted over the phone and via email to determine the roles that had been played.
Transcripts were subsequently analyzed and individual activities were categorized.
Results: Librarian skills naturally lent themselves to disaster scenarios in which accurate information was
needed in a short time frame. Health information was of particular importance and medical librarians made significant
contributions by disseminating materials to first responders and health providers working in evacuation shelters.
Conclusions: Based on the findings of the investigation, a strong case can be made for librarian involvement in federal,
provincial/state, and local disaster response activities.
Refocusing the HSL: Shifting to a services paradigm Peggy O'Neil, London Health Sciences Centre,
Shauna-Lee Konrad, London Health Sciences Centre
and
Jessica McEwan, London Regional Cancer Centre, London Health Sciences Centre
Program Objective: Primary - To refocus the library's role within the organization toward professional services instead
of technical services and collections, and thereby solidify the library as an integral contributor to patient care,
teaching and research. Secondary - To introduce a liaison-librarian model of professional services with subject-specific
portfolios.
Setting: Teaching hospital library in London, Ontario.
Participants: Staff of the London Health Sciences Centre.
Program: The library shifted its philosophy and respective labour mix to include 6 librarians. Existing services
were re-evaluated while new services were considered. A liaison-librarian model was adopted to target specific
hospital departments and build client relationships. Through regional and organizational partnerships, the focus and
extent of library collections changed, minimizing technical services. Intentional and systematic promotion of the new
library focus and model was conducted.
Results:
Use of existing services has significantly increased, and new services have been added to the suite of librarian services.
The information literacy program has been enhanced. The liaison model has been widely accepted within the organization.
The successes and challenges of adopting the new focus and model for the library will be discussed.
Conclusion:
In the digital age, the library can continue to be relevant to users by moving from a traditional collections-focused model
to one centered on excellent professional services. Within the health sciences context, library services are crucial in
supporting evidence-based practice through enhanced access to, and effective use of information by health care professionals.
The liaison model is an effective way of engendering trust and confidence between the librarian and health care practitioner.
On the cutting edge - experiences of a Clinical Surgical Librarian Marina Englesakis, BA (Hons), MLIS
Information Specialist, for Surgical Services, Neuroscience, & Medical Education
Health Sciences Library, University Health Network, Toronto General Hospital and Amy Faulkner, Information Specialist at the University Health Network, Toronto.
Program Objective: The Clinical Surgical Librarian (CSL) service is designed to go 'beyond the library walls' to address
the research needs of General Surgery staff.
Setting: The Surgical Quality of Care Rounds that are held every Thursday afternoon at the University Health Network,
Toronto, Canada. These rounds can include discussions of professional practice, assessment of morbidity/mortality for
surgical patients, and presentations on surgical topics.
Participants: Regular attendees at rounds are General Surgery staff, residents, and medical students.
Members of other departments are invited for discussions of non-surgical aspects of morbidity/mortality.
Program: The "Clinical Surgical Librarian" (CSL) role is a supplemental function of the Information Specialist position.
In this role, the CSL attends the weekly Surgical Quality of Care Rounds and upon request, provides research support to
surgical staff, residents, and/or medical students. As topics arising from discussions in one week's session may be presented
at the next week's Rounds, searches of/for the requested material must be timely.
Results: The impact of the CSL has been a demonstrable increase in an awareness of library services, and use of the
Information Specialist both within and outside of Rounds. Other positive effects include invitations to provide database
search training to surgeons attending the "Annual Update in General Surgery" conference.
Conclusion: The function of Clinical Surgical Librarian will continue to be a part of the Information Specialist position.
In the future rounds, the CSL will conduct 'teaching vignettes' incorporating Evidence-Based Medicine searching principles
and database search training. In addition, it has been a learning experience for the librarian.
Implementing an integrated information prescription model in family medicine Francesca Frati, MLIS, Herzl Family Practice Centre, SMBD Jewish General Hospital, Montréal, Québec
Program objective: To meet the health information needs of patients, families, and health professionals at point of
care within one academic family medicine teaching unit, supported by the adjacent hospital library, with a librarian on
site as a new member of the healthcare team.
Setting: The Herzl Family Practice Centre (HFPC), a McGill University family medicine teaching unit in Montreal.
Participants: Patients and families, health professionals and support staff at the HPFC.
Program: This Information Rx model sees the librarian acting as a member of the healthcare team,
providing support at point of care. HPs are encouraged to write "information Rx" which patients can
then fill during consultation with the librarian. The service is located next to the Centre's waiting area.
Patients and family members can drop in or make appointments with the librarian independently of their HP.
Consultations with patients are documented in the charts. The library's Patient and Family Resource Centre
acts as a support and provides access to resources, including a print collection.
Results: This session
explores the process that resulted in the creation of this innovative new service, describes the service
and shares some lessons learned several months after implementation.
Conclusion: This example shows how
collaborating with healthcare professionals outside of the library setting can enable a librarian to be
integrated into the healthcare team, facilitate a health information service being tailored to the needs
of a specific community, and encourage use of the service by acting as a reminder to patients, families and HPs.
Metropolis revisited: the evolution of an interdisciplinary approach to teaching informatics at the Massachusetts
College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences Samuel King, Librarian, Health Sciences Library, Manchester Campus, MCPHS, Manchester, NH
Objective - The study of informatics is multi-disciplinary in nature. The objective of this paper is to identify opportunities
for librarians to engage in inter-disciplinary collaboration through the teaching of informatics.
Methods - The evolution of librarian taught informatics curriculum at the Massachusetts College of Pharmacy and Health
Sciences will be reviewed. This will include for credit courses taught by librarian led teams as well as librarian
participation in informatics courses within the School of Nursing. Issues and challenges working within a class class/online
hybrid and totally online environment will be discussed. The benefits of interdisciplinary teaching will be highlighted.
Results - Librarians can learn and benefit from collaboration with instructional designers, statisticians, nurses,
pharmacists and other professions in teaching a multi-disciplinary subject like informatics. We can increase the profile of
our profession, broaden our expertise and open doors to further participation within the institutional team.
Discussion - Librarian involvement in teaching informatics at MCPHS began with an NLM fellowship in informatics at Wood's
Hole resulting in the library's first for credit course, offered totally in class and including the participation of faculty
from other disciplines. The successful collaboration with the College instructional designer was essential in moving this
librarian led course to a totally virtual environment. In addition, teaming with other faculty resulted in two nursing
led hybrid courses in Boston and Manchester. Librarians have opportunities to learn from other disciplines and much to
offer through collaborative teaching. Informatics is an ideal area where these varied disciplines can join to achieve
common goals.
Promoting effective task-related Internet information seeking for healthcare professionals: oncology nurses as example Dr. Ina Fourie, Department of Information Science, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa
Background: A growing interest in using the Internet in healthcare contexts and the numerous factors affecting
information seeking by healthcare professionals have been widely noted, e.g. lack of time, computer and search skills,
opportunity to use the Internet while at work, and not realizing the importance of information for task completion and
personal development.
Objectives: The paper will address how, in a dynamic healthcare environment facing increasing patient interest in using
the Internet and being involved in decision making, healthcare professionals should be prepared to use the Internet for
effective task-related information seeking.
Discussion: Healthcare professionals are working adults with experiences, backgrounds, skills and beliefs that need to be
recognized when promoting information literacy skills. Building on their task environment and allowing them to help in
identifying examples of use in their jobs will thus be addressed. Issues that may be covered in training sessions can include:
Analysing daily tasks, the information intensity of tasks and plotting these against the value of Internet information
resources.
Exploring the value of recommended Internet information resources for daily tasks on different levels (e.g. deciding on
treatment for nausea and/or vomiting; explaining chemotherapy to patients).
Exploring the scope and limitations of web search tools (e.g. inadequacy of coverage, lack of overlap between search engines).
Exploring mechanisms to identify appropriate search terms.
Exploring the reasons for poor retrieval when using search engines and how to counter act these by using advanced search features.
Exploring the opportunities for professional development and self-fulfilment.
Effectiveness of a faculty workshop on finding evidence for teaching and learning in medicine Christopher Popovich (presenter), Faculty Development Office, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University and
Lorie Kloda (Primary Contact), MLIS, PhD Student, Centre for Medical Education, Faculty of Medicine, McGill University, Lady Meredith House, 1110 Pine Avenue West, Room 205, Montreal, QC H3A 1A3, Canada, Tel: 514.398.2698, email: lorie.kloda@mcgill.ca
Purpose of the study
This study assesses the effectiveness of an educational intervention on improving literature search skills and
confidence of medical school faculty.
Methods
Participants were invited to attend two interactive faculty development workshops on
"Searching the Literature for Evidence Based Teaching and Learning." Workshop goals included: searching
databases for literature on medical education, especially trials and systematic reviews; searching databases
of peer-reviewed literature efficiently; and, determining whether a document is available online or in the library.
Prior to the session, an electronic questionnaire, which served as both a needs assessment and pre-test, was distributed
to all registrants. During the workshop, participants completed a pre-post instrument to measure their confidence in online
literature searching. After the workshop, feedback was solicited via paper questionnaire. To measure participants' retention
of search skills and perception of such abilities, a second electronic questionnaire was distributed five months after the
workshop.
Summary of Results
Sixty-five medical school faculty members attended both workshops, which were highly rated.
Preliminary data from the pre-test indicated participants had only some basic knowledge required to search effectively.
The pre-post instrument demonstrated that although many participants were confident that they could complete several
tasks required for a search, they learned more as a result of the workshop. Data from the follow-up questionnaire are being
analyzed.
Conclusions
The revitalization of faculty members' literature search skills is an important component of continuing professional
development. This study demonstrates to what extent an educational intervention is effective in meeting this goal.
Keywords: literature searching, evidence-based practice, faculty development
Handheld Information Technologies and Medical Students: Have undergraduates outgrown PDAs? Trish Chatterley, BA, MLIS, John W. Scott Health Sciences Library, University of Alberta and
Dagmara Chojecki, John W. Scott Health Sciences Library, University of Alberta
Background:
Five years ago PDAs were all the rage, especially in health science circles. Are they still being used, or have they been
replaced by smartphones and other newer technologies? The John W. Scott Health Sciences Library at the University of Alberta
still provides access to some PDA resources, but wanted to assess whether or not the collection policy needed to be revised to
take into account more recent handheld technology patterns.
Objective:
Two librarians conducted a research project to determine use of handheld devices (PDAs, etc.) by undergraduate medical
students and assess their need for handheld resources. Results from the needs assessment will be used to inform library
collection development and customer instruction policies and practices.
Methods:
Subsequent to ethics approval, an electronic questionnaire was emailed to all undergraduate medical students at the
U of A. Following analysis of survey results, focus groups were held with students in both pre-clinical and clinical
years of their program to gather more in-depth information about handheld usage.
Results:
This study is currently underway, results are forthcoming.
Discussion:
As librarians, we want to provide access to resources in the formats most preferred by our customers,
thereby facilitating knowledge use and adding value to the student experience.
Results from this study will enable our library to adapt current practices to best meet the needs of our
students.
Hunting for Health Statistics? We can Help! Liz Dennett, Institute of Health Economics/University of Alberta, JW Scott Health Sciences Library
Background: Many organizations worldwide generate health data and statistics, but there was no one database that
facilitated access to this information. As a result, searching for these statistics was often a time-consuming and
frustrating task.
Objective: Our goal was to create a searchable portal that offered a single access point to the plethora of
web-based health statistics available from national and global agencies.
Methods: We developed a list of potential producers of health statistics and reviewed their websites.
This was supplemented by a review of various library guides to health statistics as well as general Internet
searches. When statistical products were identified, information about each was entered into an Access database
we had created. Tags were assigned in such fields as disease category and geography. A simple web interface was
then produced and the database content was uploaded, making the portal freely available for use. The interface
offers both browsing and search functions.
Results: Though work on the database is still in progress, our product - a simple, freely available portal to
health statistics - will be of use to information specialists, researchers, and health professionals.
Discussion: At present, the database has a largely Canadian focus and is limited to English language resources.
As we continue to populate the database, additional categories and regions will be represented. We plan to solicit
feedback about the portal and incorporate suggestions into both the user interface and content.
PubMed Central Canada: A partnership that will increase research access and application Geoff Hynes M.Sc., Senior Policy Analyst / Analyste principal des politiques
Knowledge Synthesis and Exchange / La synthèse et l'échange des connaissances
Canadian Institutes of Health Research / Instituts de recherche en santé du Canada
and
Donna Meighan, M.L.S
Partnership Development Officer, Health Portfolio
Canada Institute for Scientific and Technical Information
Since the 17th century, the scholarly journal has been a central means of disseminating new findings and knowledge.
Today, thanks to the internet, open access is transforming the way in which research findings are disseminated.
Open access publishing enables research results to be accessible more quickly by researchers and research users worldwide.
Open access recognizes that advancements in science are made possible through widespread and barrier-free access to research.
With the announcement of its Policy on Access to Research Outputs in September 2007, the Canadian Institutes of
Health Research (CIHR) became the open access leader amongst funding agencies in Canada. This new policy requires
CIHR researchers to make every effort to ensure that their peer-reviewed publications are freely accessible online
within six months of publication.
As part of the implementation plan for this policy, CIHR and the Canada Institute for Scientific and Technical
Information (CISTI) are partnering to create a national, web-based repository of health sciences literature that
will be part of the PubMed Central Canada (PMC) network. PMC Canada will be a tool for knowledge diffusion
and a platform for knowledge creation. By working together, CIHR and CISTI are sharing expertise to develop a valuable
resource that supports both organizations' unique mandates as well as contributes to the advancement of human health and
disease knowledge and health policies that will ultimately benefit all Canadians.
In this presentation, the systematic development of CIHR's policy will be highlighted, along with the joint work
that has begun on building PMC Canada. You will also hear about the future plans for PMC Canada and the lessons
learned in this ongoing partnership.
NurseONE is an interactive web-based portal which is home to a comprehensive list of reliable and respected sources of health information. The portal technology provides members with secure access to scholarly health information at the point of need; utilization of best practices for health care; evidence-based health information for nurses in all domains of practice; access to information for all stages of a nurses career and assists in ensuring nurses are able to remain at the forefront of their practice regardless of their geographical location.
NurseONE is the one stop shop for reliable, credible information resources on a 24/7/365 basis for nurses across Canada as they strive to make the organizational shifts and changes needed to optimize patient outcomes in our ever changing health care system. The portal context has been designed to provide a wide range of services utilizing the latest information communication technologies available to promote professional development, life-long learning, high quality, safe, ethical patient care and enhanced patient outcomes. This presentation will provide a contextual overview and demonstration of the NurseONE portal from creation to implementation, with a focus on the Helen K Mussallem e-library.